Both start at $49/month, but the billing stack and plan limits can change your shortlist. Rewardful documents Paddle Classic only; FirstPromoter has a Paddle Billing setup guide. The details below are based on vendor documentation, not hands-on tests.
SaaSAlways has not hands-on tested either product. This comparison is based on official vendor documentation. Editorial policy
Which one fits
Editorial opinion
Choose Rewardful if
You use Stripe or Paddle Classic, expect one campaign, and value a $7,500 monthly affiliate-attributed revenue allowance with unlimited affiliates on Starter. Check branding and team limits.
Choose FirstPromoter if
You use Paddle Billing or need several affiliate campaigns and flexible recurring commission rules. Starter allows $5,000 monthly affiliate revenue and up to 1,000 affiliates.
Side by side
Documented facts, not a quality ranking. “Not verified” means we have not yet confirmed it in an official source.
Rewardful compared with FirstPromoter
RRewardful
FFirstPromoter
Pricing
Paid entry, monthly
$49/month
$49/month
Billing detail
Starter: $49/month or $490/year. Affiliate revenue limits apply.
Starter: $49/month or $490/year. Plans scale with affiliate revenue.
Free plan
No
No
Free plan or trial detail
No permanent free plan is listed. A 14 day trial is available.
No permanent free plan is listed. A 14 day trial is offered without a credit card.
Pricing checked
9 Oct 2026
9 Oct 2026
Pricing model
Flat monthly fee, Free trial
Flat monthly fee, Free trial
Affiliate program features
Commission structures
Supports fixed or percentage commissions, one time and recurring rewards, and commission duration limits. Subscription changes and refunds can adjust commissions.
Fixed and percentage rewards support one time or recurring commissions. Rules can vary by product, campaign or partner; advanced commission features depend on plan.
Tracking method
Referral links and coupon attribution are supported, with configurable attribution settings and self referral detection.
Supports referral links, coupon attribution and assigned URLs, with first or last click options and a server side tracking API.
Payouts
PayPal and Wise mass payouts are supported. Optional Managed Payouts add a 3% merchant processing fee; affiliate withdrawal fees may also apply.
One-click payouts via PayPal and Stripe payout integrations can be configured, and bulk exports support other external providers. Fully managed Auto Payouts require Enterprise 2 or higher, SaaS business eligibility and account approval; affiliate withdrawal fees and payout availability vary.
Platform
Documented integrations
Native billing integrations include Stripe and Paddle Classic. Paddle Billing is not supported by the documented Paddle integration.
Documented integrations include Stripe, Paddle, Chargebee, Recurly and Braintree. A separate official guide covers Paddle Billing setup.
API available
Yes
Yes
API and webhooks detail
REST API access is included on all listed plans. A branded portal and custom domain require Growth or above.
APIs and webhooks support custom integrations. A custom domain requires Business or above.
Fit
Consider it for
Stripe or Paddle Classic subscription businesses that want recurring affiliate commissions and billing event synchronization.
SaaS teams needing recurring commissions, multiple attribution methods and several supported subscription billing integrations.
Check before choosing
Paddle Billing users, teams needing a permanent free plan, or programs that require advanced portal customization on the entry plan.
Teams seeking a permanent free plan, unlimited affiliates on Starter, or a subscription cost independent of affiliate revenue.
For Paddle Billing, FirstPromoter is the documented match of these two. For Stripe, assess Rewardful’s higher Starter affiliate-attributed revenue allowance against FirstPromoter’s campaign controls and integrations. Neither has been hands-on tested by SaaSAlways.